I recently read The Unaccountability Machine by Dan Davies and it has a great overview and summary of Stafford Beer’s The Viable Systems Model, aka Cybernetics.
I asked Claude to apply the 5 systems model to a base on Mars and it provided a useful answer I thought was worth sharing:
Let me help design a cybernetic approach to creating a viable 10,000-person civilization on Mars. We’ll use Stafford Beer’s Viable System Model to structure this complex endeavor.
First, let’s understand what makes this challenge unique. A Mars base needs to be largely self-sustaining, has severe environmental constraints, and has limited ability to get help from Earth. This means our cybernetic systems need to be especially robust and adaptable.
Let’s examine each system level:
System 1: Basic Operations
These are the fundamental activities needed for survival and functioning. We would organize these into semi-autonomous operational units:
Life Support Operations:
- Air production and recycling facilities
- Water reclamation and purification systems
- Food production (hydroponic farms, protein cultivation)
- Waste management and recycling
Habitat Operations:
- Living quarters maintenance
- Power generation and distribution
- Construction and repair
- Environmental control systems
Community Operations:
- Healthcare facilities
- Education centers
- Recreation facilities
- Social spaces
Resource Operations:
- Mining and resource extraction
- Manufacturing and fabrication
- Supply chain management
- Storage and inventory
Each of these operational units would need its own management structure and the ability to handle day-to-day decisions autonomously. For example, the hydroponic farms would need to manage their own growing cycles, maintenance schedules, and staff rotations.
System 2: Coordination
This level prevents conflicts between operational units and manages shared resources. Key coordination mechanisms would include:
Resource Scheduling System:
- Energy allocation between different facilities
- Water distribution management
- Oxygen distribution coordination
- Shared equipment scheduling
Emergency Response Protocols:
- Clear procedures for various types of emergencies
- Coordination mechanisms between different response teams
- Resource reallocation procedures during crises
Information Management:
- Centralized data collection and sharing
- Communication protocols between units
- Standard operating procedures
System 3: Integration and Control
This level manages the current state of the colony and optimizes operations. It would include:
Central Colony Management:
- Resource allocation decisions
- Performance monitoring
- Quality control
- Risk management
The management team would need real-time data about critical systems and the ability to quickly reallocate resources when needed. They would negotiate resource bargains with each operational unit – for example, agreeing on power usage limits in exchange for production targets.
System 4: Intelligence and Planning
This system would be crucial for long-term survival. It would need to:
Monitor External Environment:
- Mars weather patterns
- Solar radiation levels
- Resource exploration data
- Earth communication and supply schedules
Plan for Future Development:
- Population growth management
- Technology development
- Resource sustainability planning
- Emergency scenario planning
Research and Development:
- New technologies for Mars conditions
- Improved life support systems
- Better resource utilization methods
System 5: Identity and Policy
This highest level would maintain the colony’s purpose and values. It would need to:
Set Fundamental Policies:
- Population growth targets
- Resource usage principles
- Research priorities
- Social organization principles
Maintain Colony Identity:
- Cultural development
- Ethical frameworks
- Governance structures
- Long-term vision
Critical Features for Mars Context:
Redundancy:
Given the hostile environment, each critical system would need multiple layers of backup and the ability to reconfigure quickly if parts fail.
Information Flow:
The communication system would need to be especially robust, with multiple channels for critical information and clear alert mechanisms for problems.
Adaptation Capability:
The system must be able to learn and evolve as we discover more about living on Mars. This means building in flexibility and experimentation capacity.
Resource Management:
Given the scarcity of resources, the system needs sophisticated methods for optimization and reuse of all materials.
The key to making this work would be ensuring that each level has:
- Sufficient autonomy to handle its responsibilities
- Clear communication channels with other levels
- Appropriate backup systems and redundancy
- The ability to adapt as we learn more about Mars conditions
For those wanting to know more, I suggest Dan’s book The Unaccountability Machine.
Leave a Reply